The Best Lawn Aerators – Buyer’s Guide

by Max - last update on

Lawn Aerators Badge

The Best Lawn Aerators to Buy Now

We reviewed over 38 lawn aerators to find the top 10 picks. Take a look at our reviews of the top lawn aerators and read our buyers’ guide to learn about the features and costs to consider.

10 Top-Rated Lawn Aerators

 

Agri-Fab 48-Inch Tow Plug Aerator


Agri-Fab 48-Inch Tow Plug Aerator

Agri-Fab’s 48-inch tow plug aerator loosens soil by pulling 3-inch plugs out of compacted yard dirt to let nutrients reach lawn roots in the form of air and water. With a weight tray that can hold 175 pounds of additional weight, this aerator has the capability to penetrate deep into the soil. Its 32 plug aerator knives are arrayed in three welded sections that rotate independently to achieve maximum aeration coverage, and the blades are self-sharpening to minimize maintenance requirements.

The 48-inch plug aerator is easy to transport, thanks to its flat-free tires that roll smoothly. It can be hooked up to any tractor, with the transport handle easily reachable to facilitate the raising and lowering of the aerator while in motion across the lawn.

Benefits
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Works well on steep grades
  • Good choice for large yards
  • Excellent penetration
  • Easy to clean
Drawbacks
  • Assembly instructions aren’t in the most optimal order
  • Handle can be difficult to reach from some tractors

 

Yard Butler Lawn Aerator


Yard Butler Lawn Aerator

The Yard Butler is a handheld lawn aerator and dethatcher that allows water, air, and fertilizer to penetrate soil down to a lawn’s roots while pruning roots for vigorous growth. Designed for long-lasting use, this 37-inch aerator is ideal for aerating small yards. As it removes 3.5-inch plugs, it reduces soil compaction and deposits microorganisms on the lawn’s surface to help resist drought and heat.

This heavy-duty coring aerator is made of powder-coated steel for durability and comfort in the hand. The foot bar incorporated into the design allows for extra leverage without placing any strain on the back during aeration.

Benefits
  • Ideal for small to medium lawn
  • Easy to use
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Goes where a tractor-pulled aerator can’t
  • Design prevents back pain
Drawbacks
  • Middle bar can hit user’s knee during aeration
  • Clogs easily with wet soil

 

Abco Tech Lawn Aerator Shoes


Abco Tech Lawn Aerator Shoes

Abcosport’s lawn aerator spike shoes make it easy to loosen up compacted soil so that air and water can bring nutrients to the roots of the lawn. These durable shoes use extremely sharp nails to penetrate the soil with minimal effort required. Gardeners can strap the shoes on over their own everyday footwear, using the tough metal buckles to hold them in place, and then aerate the soil while mowing the lawn.

The sturdy plastic design of these lawn aerator shoes provides good foot support, and the straps that hold the shoes on are adjustable for better comfort and fit on any foot. Each shoe features 13 anti-corrosive, 48mm metal spikes to dig deep into the soil, promoting water absorption and airflow with every step.

Benefits
  • Easy to assemble
  • Easy to use
  • Ideal for use on a flat yard
  • Faster aeration than using an aerator fork
  • Provides a great workout as a bonus
Drawbacks
  • Spikes have a tendency to bend with rough use
  • Straps are difficult to adjust

 

Best Choice Products 18-inch Rolling Lawn Aerator


Best Choice Products 18-inch Rolling Lawn Aerator

The 18-inch rolling lawn aerator from Best Choice Products is a gardening tool that’s effective and ultra-easy to use. Its solid steel spikes perforate soil to facilitate air exchange, as well as absorption of water and fertilizer, and they also help reduce puddling on the lawn.

The dual plastic wheels of this aerator roll easily over grass, and the long, 50-inch handle allows flexibility in reaching into small areas of grass while providing ease of use. The simple design of this aerator promises a long lifetime of use without complex assembly or maintenance required.

Benefits
  • Cost-effective
  • Penetrates soil even when muddy
  • Good for small areas of lawn
  • Easy to assemble
  • Works well on soft soil
Drawbacks
  • Could use more spikes
  • Requires some physical strength to use

 

Brinly PA-40BH Tow Behind Plug Aerator


Brinly PA-40BH Tow Behind Plug Aerator

The Brinly tow-behind plug aerator features 24 heat-treated steel plugging spoons that remove 3-inch soil plugs from the soil. The sharpened ends easily penetrate compacted soil, enabling aeration and opening a way for fertilizer and seed to be implanted. The strong tines are welded to three sections that rotate independently to facilitate even penetration on turns.  Each plugging spoon can be served or replaced independently if needed.

A universal, single-pin hitch makes it easy to attach this tow-behind aerator to lawn tractors and ATVs, with a single lever enabling transport mode. The aerator’s 10-inch rubber tread tires roll smoothly across driveways and over roots to maintain forward momentum, and the enclosed weight tray holds up to 150 pounds to add pressure when aerating tightly compacted soil.

Benefits
  • Ideal for large lawns
  • Sturdy design and construction
  • Smooth raising and lowering mechanism
  • Tows well
  • Works well in reverse
Drawbacks
  • Requires advanced assembly
  • Tire bolts hit the spikes

 

CABASAA Lawn Aerator Shoes Heavy Duty Sandals with Spikes


CABASAA Lawn Aerator Shoes Heavy Duty Sandals with Spikes

The lawn aerator shoes from CABASAA use heavy-duty spikes to aerate a lawn while walking on it. Each sandal features 13 steel spikes to dig 2.2 inches into the soil, loosening dirt to allow water, air, and nutrients to circulate and reach roots. The sandals, which strap on over athletic shoes or work boots, feature dual adjustable straps with sturdy metal buckles. The straps are positioned to provide heel support while opening easily and making sure the sandals stay put.

These lawn aerator sandals are easy to assemble, and they fit all foot sizes, men and women alike. They’re far less expensive than tow-behind aerators, and they require less physical strength and effort than handheld devices, making lawn aeration as easy as possible.

Benefits
  • Easy to use during mowing or seeding
  • Sturdy construction
  • Works even on tough soil
  • Ideal for small areas of lawn
  • Sandals fit well over shoes
Drawbacks
  • Straps can be difficult to adjust
  • Nails are too close together for some uses

 

Craftsman Tow Spike Aerator


Craftsman Tow Spike Aerator

The tow-behind spike aerator from Craftsman uses star-shaped spikes to penetrate 2.5 inches deep into the soil to open a way for air and water to reach the grass roots. At only 40 pounds, the aerator is lightweight compared to most other tow-behind aerators, making it easy to carry and maneuver. It comes with a weight tray that holds up to 90 pounds to add pressure and penetration during aeration.

This tow-behind aerator features a universal hitch that connects easily to all types of tractors or riding lawn mowers, and it adjusts to accommodate tractors of various heights. Its width of 36 inches lets gardeners cover large lawns quickly, and its 10-gauge steel frame is constructed for durability and extended use.

Benefits
  • Easy to assemble
  • Affordable price
  • Well-made and durable
  • Ideal for large lawns
  • Pulls well behind riding mowers
Drawbacks
  • Doesn’t work in reverse
  • Instructions are hard to follow

 

EnvyGreen Lawn Aerator Shoes


EnvyGreen Lawn Aerator Shoes

These slip-on lawn aerator shoes from EnvyGreen are designed to facilitate the ability of oxygen and fertilizer to reach grass roots while improving water drainage. The boots’ 2.1-inch spikes work well with sandy, loam, or clay soil, and they make it possible to provide full aeration to even the smallest or most hard-to-reach patches of lawn.

These spike aerators use a proprietary strap design to hold the gardening boots on securely, and they hold up to 220 pounds. No assembly is required, so gardeners can begin improving their soil immediately without hassle. One size fits all with these aerators, which come with a 100% money-back guarantee.

Benefits
  • Back strap helps them work well with small feet
  • Spikes penetrate soil well
  • Straps keep shoes in place reliably
  • No assembly required
  • Fun way to aerate a lawn
Drawbacks
  • Straps wear out quickly
  • Spikes get stuck in soil easily

 

Goplus Rolling Lawn Aerator


Goplus Rolling Lawn Aerator

This manual rolling lawn aerator from Goplus breaks up compacted soil to allow oxygen and water to reach the roots of the lawn, softening the soil to permit expansion and free flow of nutrients. It also facilitates the deep watering of lawns and works well with sandy and clay soils.

This lightweight aerator is easy to use, and its 50-inch, three-piece handle provides the torque needed to dig into the soil without much effort on the gardener’s part. Sharp metal spikes dig deep into the ground, while the plastic wheels allow smooth rolling across all surfaces. An ergonomic rubber grip makes this aerator comfortable to operate.

Benefits
  • Easy to assemble
  • Cost-effective solution
  • Ideal for use on a small yard
  • Heavy-duty construction
  • Useful for seeding
Drawbacks
  • Too lightweight to dig deep without added effort
  • Can damage sprinkler heads if user isn’t careful

 

KedsHome Lawn Aerator Shoes


KedsHome Lawn Aerator Shoes

These sturdy lawn aerator shoes let gardeners aerate a lawn just by walking across it, breaking up compacted soil to increase absorption of air, water, and nutrients. They work well on any type of soil, including sand and clay, providing healthy aeration for a fraction of the cost of other types of aerators.

These KedsHome shoes feature 26 heavy-duty, 2.2-inch spikes to dig into tough soil, as well as four adjustable straps per shoe, each with a sturdy metal buckle to secure the shoe. The strong plastic base allows gardeners to feel confident as they press the spikes into soil, and the shoe is backed by a 100% money-back guarantee.

Benefits
  • Cost-effective way to aerate lawn
  • Easy to assemble
  • Provides deep penetration
  • Ease of use
  • Great for smaller lawns
Drawbacks
  • Straps come undone easily
  • Poor customer service

 

Lawn Aerator Buying Guide

What to look for

Choosing the right type of aerator depends on the size and type of your lawn, the soil in your area, the amount of time and effort you want to spend aerating your lawn, and your budget. Manual aerators cost far less than towable versions, but they require a lot more work on your part.

Key elements to consider when choosing an aerator are how deep the spikes dig into the soil (the deeper, the better), how difficult the unit is to assemble, and how much physical strength the type of aerator requires. Among the main varieties of aerators are:

  • Shoe spike aerators. These aerators require the least financial output, so you can try them out without a significant investment. They’re a good choice for gardeners with small, flat lawns, but the elderly or those with unstable footing should probably avoid them, as it can be easy to fall off them. They’re easy to use while mowing, but they provide the least aeration of all types.
  • Manual aerators. These handheld tools are ideal for aerating small areas, such as sections of lawn surrounded by footpaths or stairs. However, if you have a lawn of any size, you may find them less effective. Look for aerators that remove cores from the soil for the best effect.
  • Tow-behind aerators. These highly effective aerators are designed for use with lawn tractors or riding mowers and are a great choice for large lawns. Look for models that hitch to the tractor easily and that can be controlled while still seated. Many models feature weight trays that allow you to add up to 150 pounds to push the spikes further into the grass.

Cost

The cost of a lawn aerator depends on the type of device. Lawn aerator shoes, which run in the $20 to $35 range, are by far the least expensive choice, but they are also the least effective for all types of lawns. Handheld lawn aerators, such as the Yard Butler aerator and dethatcher, can be found in the $30 to $50 range, and manual rolling aerators tend to go for anywhere from $35 to $65. Tow-behind aerators, which are the best choice for very large lawns, can be priced anywhere from $80 to $230, depending on their size and construction quality.